Our Common Holy Day Origin

Sent by Craig White in 2010 (Australia) Notes by Dr Tom Roberts, PhD
The Beginnings of the Seventh Month Movement In modern times the annual festival days have been a constant source of debate. In the 1840’s, during the Millerite Period, the Seventh Month Movement appeared. Studies surrounding the Day of Atonement and the controversies about how to interpret Daniel 8:14 which lead to the Great Disappointment of October 22, 1843, and October 22, 1844, lie at the foundations of this movement. Portions grew into the Midnight Cry subcategory but, as we shall see, the Holy Days were adopted by other related Sabbatarian groups. The Millerite Period has been called by some “The Movement of the Great Awakening”. L.E. Froom reports in his Movement of Destiny that over seventy denominations fed the Millerite Movement. But just how large the Seventh Month Movement actually became and the leaders it impacted is a matter of conjecture. Some have estimated that, at its peak, it may have had as many as 300,000 adherents. If this is true, it would not be surprising for other groups to be impacted by its teachings. (for more information see the Seventh Day Adventist Encyclopedia, Commentary Reference Series, Vol 10, pg. 1337-1338) Mormonism and Holy Days During the same time period, a movement within Mormonism emerged in 1848 lead by James Strang who founded the Hebrew Mormonism Movement. They believed in One God, the annual Holy Days, the weekly Sabbath and the teachings of the Book of Mormon. Later, in the 1970’s, David L Roberts would lead a breakaway group of over 11,000 Sabbatarian and Holy Day followers. (Latter Day Saints and the Sabbath, Russell J. Thomsen, pg. 24-33, Divergent Paths of the Restoration, Steven L. Shields, pp. 177-178) The Church of God Seventh Day Connection In 1858, Gilbert Cramer from the Marion Party, founded eight churches which would ultimately become the Church of God Seventh Day. Out of this ministry arose the Remnant of Israel under the leadership of G. G. Rupert who definitely advocated the meaning of Holy Day observance. (“Remnant of Israel”, G. G. Rupert, Vol 10, No. 11, September 1929) Some today are suggesting that G. G. Rupert was a delegate at the 1888 Seventh Day Adventist Conference which began the change of direction of the SDA Church from its founders with the departure of Wagner and Jones. This conference was very significant because its theme was “Righteousness by Faith” and was needed to free Sabbatarians from legalism. Unfortunately, as the years passed, many of the founding voices of Adventism who once gave support to the Seventh Month Movement were no longer influential. Ellen White even stated that the Adventist camp meetings should replicate the Feast of Tabernacles. (see booklet Ellen White Speaks Out on the Work of the Jewish People, Sanford Howard) Wagner and Jones argued that the Holy Days were not the subject of the “weak and beggarly elements” described in the writings of Paul but the “weak and beggarly elements” were indeed forms of fallen Judaism mixed with pagan observances. Today, a growing number of scholars such as Troy Martin, Mark Nanas and Paul Torazi support this view. It should be noted, that in 1870, D. T. Niles and other scholars would begin to see the meaning of the Holy Days contained in the Book of Revelation. This would later be enlarged by Frank Holbrook and expanded further by Lewis F Were in the 1980’s. However, in the early 1900’s, many Adventist writers such as F. C. Gilbert (The Jewish Problem and Daniel and the Sanctuary) tied Adventist prophecy to the Day of Atonement and other festival days. He intended to establish Jewish missions in the city of New York but the $1500 in contributions to this work were never forwarded to him from the General Conference of the SDA Church. The Methodist Influence Upon Sabbatarianism From the 1840’s until 1917, Methodism in the United States had three major Sabbatarian outgrowths. Teachings from Methodism which were adopted by the founders of these groups were the doctrine of man as soul-ish being, the free agency of man, the eschatological Kingdom of God which will heal creation at the end of time and the doctrine of holiness and sanctification, vegetarianism and emphasis on healing through herbs and natural practices. Gilbert Cramer who founded the Church of God Seventh Day in 1858 had been a Methodist. Ellen G White grew up in the Methodist Church until she was a teenager. Then, in 1917, a former Methodist bishop named Johnson founded with two Adventist leaders the denomination called the House of God. He advocated the Kingdom of God on earth and the keeping of the annual festivals. This history of his ministry reaches back into the 1890’s with missions to Africa and today, has approximately 10 million members worldwide. Non-Adventist writers such as Larkin with his book Dispensational Truths were also very influential in bringing the Holy Day concept to Christian readers in the 1930’s. Thus Herbert Armstrong would have had many sources from within the Church of God 7^th Day tradition such as A. N. Duggar and Dodd and G. G. Rupert on which to base his Holy Day theology. Adventism’s Attempts to Whitewash Their Beginnings By the 1950’s, Adventism was undergoing many changes. The church was attempting to be more evangelical in its emphasis on Christ with a grace orientation. L. E. Froom, a fantastic historian, who problematically, downplayed the role of the Seventh Month Movement as well as Ellen White’s fallen nature of Christ, met with Walter Martin and Donald Gray Barnhouse. These meetings resulted in the 1957 publication, Questions on Doctrine. Not all Adventists scholars were pleased with this publication. Even Zondervaan, the evangelical publisher, questioned Walter Martin on the lack of follow up in several areas such as Froom’s statements about 70 trinitarian denominations being in the formation of Adventist theology and the non-trinitarian leanings of Uriah Smith, Wagner and Jones in the beginning of Adventist history. Walter Martin simply touted his credentials as proof of the excellent scholarship for his part of this publication as a defense of its legitimacy. (The Word Was Made Flesh – One Hundred Years of Seventh-day Adventist Christology 1852-1952, Ralph Larson, pp. 292-300) As the years progressed, Adventist scholars such as N. L. Andreason, Raymond Cottrell, Ken Richards, Desmond Ford, and many others began to question the classical Adventist positions taught about the history of their beginnings and the direction the church was taking. There were those who wanted to go back to the non-trinitarian, Holy Day, Kingdom of God on earth positions of the church. Others such as Desmond Ford, wanted the church to move in an evangelical direction while some at La Sierra University have tried to place the church on a more progressive path. Once again, the church is beginning to denounce all feast day keepers. Angel Rodriguez, PhD, and others have denounced the entire feast day movement. In spite of this, the ethos of feast day movements are still behind the thinking of much of Seventh Day Adventist theology. One such example is Leslie Hardinge’s In the Shadow of His Sacrifice. He does an absolutely brilliant job of teaching Christianity the meaning of the Holy Days and the lessons that should impact their thinking about the Messiah. Today there is a growing but small number of small groups of Adventist Holy Day Keepers who are attempting to resurrect the Seventh Month Movement in the Adventist Church. Dr. John Vandenberg is leading the charge along with a few other scholars and pastors by showing the Seventh Month Movement should never have been buried in Adventist history but instead modified to exclude its theological errors. It should have retained the spirit of Holy Day keeping in the worship and the life of the church. Let us all pray and support this movement and fellowship with them as offer our love and service.

Sent by Craig White in 2010 (Australia)
Notes by Dr Tom Roberts, PhD

The Beginnings of the Seventh Month Movement
In modern times the annual festival days have been a constant source of debate. In the 1840’s, during the Millerite Period, the Seventh Month Movement appeared. Studies surrounding the Day of Atonement and the controversies about how to interpret Daniel 8:14 which lead to the Great Disappointment of October 22, 1843, and October 22, 1844, lie at the foundations of this movement. Portions grew into the Midnight Cry subcategory but, as we shall see, the Holy Days were adopted by other related Sabbatarian groups. The Millerite Period has been called by some “The Movement of the Great Awakening”. L.E. Froom reports in his Movement of Destiny that over seventy denominations fed the Millerite Movement. But just how large the Seventh Month Movement actually became and the leaders it impacted is a matter of conjecture. Some have estimated that, at its peak, it may have had as many as 300,000 adherents. If this is true, it would not be surprising for other groups to be impacted by its teachings. (for more information see the Seventh Day Adventist Encyclopedia, Commentary Reference Series, Vol 10, pg. 1337-1338)

Mormonism and Holy Days
During the same time period, a movement within Mormonism emerged in 1848 lead by James Strang who founded the Hebrew Mormonism Movement. They believed in One God, the annual Holy Days, the weekly Sabbath and the teachings of the Book of Mormon. Later, in the 1970’s, David L Roberts would lead a breakaway group of over 11,000 Sabbatarian and Holy Day followers. (Latter Day Saints and the Sabbath, Russell J. Thomsen, pg. 24-33, Divergent Paths of the Restoration, Steven L. Shields, pp. 177-178)

The Church of God Seventh Day Connection
In 1858, Gilbert Cramer from the Marion Party, founded eight churches which would ultimately become the Church of God Seventh Day. Out of this ministry arose the Remnant of Israel under the leadership of G. G. Rupert who definitely advocated the meaning of Holy Day observance. (“Remnant of Israel”, G. G. Rupert, Vol 10, No. 11, September 1929) Some today are suggesting that G. G. Rupert was a delegate at the 1888 Seventh Day Adventist Conference which began the change of direction of the SDA Church from its founders with the departure of Wagner and Jones. This conference was very significant because its theme was “Righteousness by Faith” and was needed to free Sabbatarians from legalism. Unfortunately, as the years passed, many of the founding voices of Adventism who once gave support to the Seventh Month Movement were no longer influential. Ellen White even stated that the Adventist camp meetings should replicate the Feast of Tabernacles. (see booklet Ellen White Speaks Out on the Work of the Jewish People, Sanford Howard) Wagner and Jones argued that the Holy Days were not the subject of the “weak and beggarly elements” described in the writings of Paul but the “weak and beggarly elements” were indeed forms of fallen Judaism mixed with pagan observances. Today, a growing number of scholars such as Troy Martin, Mark Nanas and Paul Torazi support this view. It should be noted, that in 1870, D. T. Niles and other scholars would begin to see the meaning of the Holy Days contained in the Book of Revelation. This would later be enlarged by Frank Holbrook and expanded further by Lewis F Were in the 1980’s. However, in the early 1900’s, many Adventist writers such as F. C. Gilbert (The Jewish Problem and Daniel and the Sanctuary) tied Adventist prophecy to the Day of Atonement and other festival days. He intended to establish Jewish missions in the city of New York but the $1500 in contributions to this work were never forwarded to him from the General Conference of the SDA Church.

The Methodist Influence Upon Sabbatarianism
From the 1840’s until 1917, Methodism in the United States had three major Sabbatarian outgrowths. Teachings from Methodism which were adopted by the founders of these groups were the doctrine of man as soul-ish being, the free agency of man, the eschatological Kingdom of God which will heal creation at the end of time and the doctrine of holiness and sanctification, vegetarianism and emphasis on healing through herbs and natural practices. Gilbert Cramer who founded the Church of God Seventh Day in 1858 had been a Methodist. Ellen G White grew up in the Methodist Church until she was a teenager. Then, in 1917, a former Methodist bishop named Johnson founded with two Adventist leaders the denomination called the House of God. He advocated the Kingdom of God on earth and the keeping of the annual festivals. This history of his ministry reaches back into the 1890’s with missions to Africa and today, has approximately 10 million members worldwide.

Non-Adventist writers such as Larkin with his book Dispensational Truths were also very influential in bringing the Holy Day concept to Christian readers in the 1930’s. Thus Herbert Armstrong would have had many sources from within the Church of God 7^th Day tradition such as A. N. Duggar and Dodd and G. G. Rupert on which to base his Holy Day theology.

Adventism’s Attempts to Whitewash Their Beginnings
By the 1950’s, Adventism was undergoing many changes. The church was attempting to be more evangelical in its emphasis on Christ with a grace orientation. L. E. Froom, a fantastic historian, who problematically, downplayed the role of the Seventh Month Movement as well as Ellen White’s fallen nature of Christ, met with Walter Martin and Donald Gray Barnhouse. These meetings resulted in the 1957 publication, Questions on Doctrine. Not all Adventists scholars were pleased with this publication. Even Zondervaan, the evangelical publisher, questioned Walter Martin on the lack of follow up in several areas such as Froom’s statements about 70 trinitarian denominations being in the formation of Adventist theology and the non-trinitarian leanings of Uriah Smith, Wagner and Jones in the beginning of Adventist history. Walter Martin simply touted his credentials as proof of the excellent scholarship for his part of this publication as a defense of its legitimacy. (The Word Was Made Flesh – One Hundred Years of Seventh-day Adventist Christology 1852-1952, Ralph Larson, pp. 292-300)

As the years progressed, Adventist scholars such as N. L. Andreason, Raymond Cottrell, Ken Richards, Desmond Ford, and many others began to question the classical Adventist positions taught about the history of their beginnings and the direction the church was taking. There were those who wanted to go back to the non-trinitarian, Holy Day, Kingdom of God on earth positions of the church. Others such as Desmond Ford, wanted the church to move in an evangelical direction while some at La Sierra University have tried to place the church on a more progressive path. Once again, the church is beginning to denounce all feast day keepers. Angel Rodriguez, PhD, and others have denounced the entire feast day movement. In spite of this, the ethos of feast day movements are still behind the thinking of much of Seventh Day Adventist theology. One such example is Leslie Hardinge’s In the Shadow of His Sacrifice. He does an absolutely brilliant job of teaching Christianity the meaning of the Holy Days and the lessons that should impact their thinking about the Messiah.

Today there is a growing but small number of small groups of Adventist Holy Day Keepers who are attempting to resurrect the Seventh Month Movement in the Adventist Church. Dr. John Vandenberg is leading the charge along with a few other scholars and pastors by showing the Seventh Month Movement should never have been buried in Adventist history but instead modified to exclude its theological errors. It should have retained the spirit of Holy Day keeping in the worship and the life of the church.

Let us all pray and support this movement and fellowship with them as offer our love and service.